Hi everyone
The topic we are going to discuss today
is "Extort a Confession through Torture"
Suppose the police had arrested
a suspected terrorist
We also know he had placed a time bomb
in a crowded place
and it was activated
Time pass minute by minute
He denied that he is a terrorist
and does not tell where he places the bomb
I would like to ask, will you torture him
until he tells you
And if doing so, do you think it is right or wrong
Of course it is right. No matter what,
saving people is the most important thing
So...
Whoever agrees with his opinion,
please raise your hand
Good, thank you
From the point of utilitarianism
If the pain of a criminal
could exchange several hundreds of life
This viewpoint is not wrong
Today, I am not going to tell you any preachment
I just want to raise a few case studies to
inspire you to think of
what is right and what is wrong
Anyone here have
the chance promoted Commissioner,
Senior Superintendent
and senior law enforcer, therefore...
It is crucial for you on right and wrong
Let god decide
If it is the front, you are fine.
Otherwise, you have to die
"Siu Ming Visits Guangzhou"
"Rides the train, fast so fast"
"Ma ma what to buy?"
"For our best friends, uncle and aunt?"
You are very noisy, Laughing Sir!
My buddy said you are very noisy
Pick the ball back!
Time's up for leisure; go back to your cell!
We will temporary keep this bag for you
Sign here if you do not have any questions
Fok Tin-yam, your number here is 77015
Yes
What crime did you commit?
Drug keeping and drug producing
What are the terms of imprisonment of
You would like to apply for a visit...
so you can continue your psychological therapy
for your patient?
Yes
This is approved
Thank you, sir.
Bring him back to the cell
Yes, sir!
Get in
You are too bossy.
Do you think you are still a police?
Here is the prison
Sit down!
Sit down and eat!
You had taken my seat
I will leave after I finish
I can't eat
I will leave after I finish. Excuse me
I had killed someone...
I had eaten human flash. No matter who you are...
Do you believe that I will bite you to bleed?
- What are you doing?
- What are you doing?
He bites me! Bites me...
I did not bite him. You see. Nothing
I just play with him
Sit down and eat now!
No more trouble!
Eat!
I had met a lot of serial killer
They like the feeling of pain
They said the more painful,
the more pleasant feeling they have
Seldom people like you,
shout even before I touch you
It's understandable, as you were raised in
a single parent family
and you were maltreated by your step father
and step mother. Leaving you full of scars
And you worry people will look down on you.
That's why you said you got the scar from fights
So people will scare of you and even adore you
However there is one thing that I can't figure out
Why did you being silly this time.
Why you admit the crime of serial homicide
Did you offend a lot of people outside
so it is safe for you to
stay in the prison, right?
Eat it. This is a treat
Laughing
Hi, Fok Tin-yam
I heard that you are a professor in university
How did you settle Kui Chuen?
I studied criminal psychology
Psychology?
Can you tell if a person
is really crazy or pretending?
Yes I can
How?
Chat with him
Focus on the content of his talking
If he pretends to be crazy...
There will be inconsistency of the same content
What if he doesn't tell anything
In this case, talk to him
Keep talking to him
and keep your eyes on his body language
His eyesight's angle,
the frequency of eye blinking and...
sometimes even moving his finger could be a leak
But to do so in-depth,
you need to study for few more years
What if...
Move two cartons outside for me!
Be quick!
Thank you, senior
Laughing Sir, I finally transfer to
Cat-A (Category A) to see you
Are you insane?
I didn't get you wrong last time
and I won't this time
I did shoot and kill someone.
The court sentenced so
You can fool of everyone,
but not me, Yeung Lap-ching
Office Lai, I think Lau Chung-chit's file
is very suspicious
It is impossible for him to
open 12 accounts in 8 banks
in less than 1 hour
Did you mention it to others?
No
I have a new mission for you
Window number 8
Laughing, I miss you so much
You girlfriend had died for so long
Can you just look at me?
Tai Chit has done nothing yet
A guy called Yeung Lap-ching had come
Tell Office Lai to take care of him
Michael!
Michael!
Michael, I am Paris. Where are you
Michael!
Michael!
Michael... Michael
Michael...
We... we are going to have a ceremony
We want to get married...
We want to get married
How come you have slept
What happened...
Get up...
Michael!
Your honor, I admit guilty
It was me who shot Michael to death
What's up, miss?
- Calm down!
- I am going to kill you, Laughing!
- Calm down!
- Let me go!
I have to kill you, Laughing!
I have to kill you!
I have to kill you!
Sit here
You agree to meet me finally
Patient, Paris Yiu, Day 1
Paris Yiu's newly married husband was murdered
that leaves her symptoms of
Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
She shows a strong will of revenge
Professor, do you like to eat egg cakes?
Yes, I do
I'll buy some and eat with you here in future
Paris Yiu, Day 5
During the healing process
The patient had already transferred
her emotion to me completely
She treats me as her deceased husband
and shares a lot of their previous experiences
I will continue the transference
therapy to treat her
Michael, I really miss you
I want to see you everyday
and have the egg cakes with you
Paris, you have to remember.
Don't stick to the past any more
OK, I promise
I would not think of anything in future,
I won't think anything
That's good
Go check them
Please feel free to look around
Miss, do you think you can get rid of me
if you go around like this?
Excuse me,
I was CIB (Criminal Intelligence Bureau) before
Sir, I was an ex-CIB
(Criminal Intelligence Bureau) police,
Yeung Lap-ching
I am also Laughing Sir's right hand
Are you a member of triad society? Right hand
Sorry, sir.
Sir, when I leave Stanley.
I discovered he has been following me
Therefore I made him here
Miss, did you say it wrong or did I mishear you?
Actually I used a sophisticated
surveillance skill to follow you here
And you have the guts saying you made me here
I am not that bad
As I need to be the coordinator of Laughing
I had studied his details thoroughly
How can't I recognize you?
Do you know what case is Laughing investigating?
Don't know yet. But obviously a big case
We are investigating
a huge corrupted police network
Their organization is very strict.
The only clue is...
in the prison. It must be
There is a Cat A (Category-A) prisoner
called Tai Chit in the prison
He was a sergeant from Narcotics Bureau
I am Sergeant Lau Chung-chit
When we followed the leak to
those corrupted police, he came out and confess
and shouldered all the bribe taking crime
I am a corrupted police
I am here to confess my crime
I know there is someone behind
who made Tai Chit to do this
Therefore we need Laughing to go into the prison
and make contact with him
I understand. I completely understand
Sir, you have told me all the stuff.
Is that means I am in?
I've checked you
Laughing needs a hand in there
Thank you, sir!
Officer Lai. I am going out
if there is no other business
Officer Lai. I am going out, too
Just a minute. I had hidden myself tightly.
How could you see me?
Officer Lai had already told me
I am here to help you with all my effort
These stuff was from someone
Okay?
It's me, Laughing
Paris Yiu thinks she should
bear the greatest responsibility
on Michael's death
She remembered few years ago,
if she had helped Michael with the lawsuit
Michael would not be put into jail
If Michael didn't put into jail,
things would not happen
Later, Paris Yiu has psychological problem
Fok Tin-yam is the one
who in charge of her therapy
Therefore I've chosen two of Fok's book for you
I think he has unique point of view
The most interesting thing is,
one of them mentioned about prison
It seems to me that he knew that
he would be put into jail
"Prison and Power"
"The Puzzle of Crime"
I want to take a bath
I want to take a bath
Just ignore him. Come here to take a bath
Are you gay?
The two smelly polices are bastards
Such a big scar, did you get this
when you were a police?
I heard that
you were full of power and prestige
in Narcotics Bureau
You also had cleared up some big cases
Why did you confess you had triad
society background while you have good future
Did anyone force you to?
Tell me
Do you know anyone from
other district and Narcotics Bureau?
Say a name, see if I know him
Don't ask me...
Please don't ask me
Why do you step on my clothes?!
Don't ask me. I don't want to tell...
Strangle this bastard! Strangle him!
I don't want to tell
Strangle him! Strangle him...
Strangle that bastard!
I don't want to tell!
Tai-chit! Tai-chit...
If you want to strangle him, you need to be harder
I had studied that it doesn't take
more than 2 minutes to strangle a person
You can do it
What's up?
Go away! Go away!
Let me do it
Tai-chit...
No!
What are you thinking
Once you hesitate,
he will resist and strangle you back
Yes, harder or he won't die
See, he is losing his breath
Just a little bit more. Come on. Strangle
Harder. He will die in your hand
Don't move!
Sit still
Don't move
It seems to me that you want to
make friends with Tai-chit
I was a police before. I just want to help him
Which department?
Make a guess
When there are a lot of people,
you got to find something to back you up
Or you keep your head down to
avoid people from recognizing you
I think what you did are not to be exposed, right
You must have offended a lot of people
Besides undercover, what else
So great
How did you get in here?
Murder
You know the dead, too
How about you?
I was set up
Criminal specialist could be set up?
Stock agent could also lose on stocks
You are a police, also a member of triad society
You have been doing undercover for so long,
do you know how to differentiate black and white?
Is there a clean cut definition
on right and wrong?
Just like I went to school when I was young,
there were a lot of poor kids
Some of them are so poor that they have to
apply for Comprehensive Social Security Assistance
And don't know why that some of them didn't get it
There was a classmate A who could not stand that
So he made up a plan to
make a fake document for him
And it finally being approved
Other classmate noticed that classmate had made it
They also asked this classmate to help
They submitted one by one and
finally it was revealed
He was dismissed by the school and
was sent to boys' home
Now, I still think that classmate
was violating the law but not committing a crime
What he did was 100% correct
He was just helping people, right?
It seems that you haven't finished your story
Your classmate A then worked very hard
He entered the university on his own effort
and studied criminology and became a professor
However their destinations are the same
He was put into jail with a classmate L
and they are squatting under
the basketball stand and boasting boringly
Actually classmate L should be a script writer
You can convergence the plot so smoothly
Hey!
Come here! Come here!
The doctor suspected that
he has psychological problem.
He will be sent to
the psychological clinic after 2 days
He had taken psychological medicine
and is acting funny now
You have to avoid stimulating him
in these two days
Do you hear me?
Tai-chit
Are you ok?
I have a friend that you also know
Senior Assistant Commissioner of Operation,
Ma Siu Kwong
Telephone number, 28603311
Chief Superintendent of Narcotics Bureau,
Choi Kam Hung
Telephone number, 28608850
Senior Superintendent, Ho Yiu Lung
Telephone number, 28608861
Time is up! Go back to your cell!
Go!
Buddy, please help my son
Brother Tak
What's up?
How is Tai-chit?
They are doing emergency rescue for him
in the hospital. Stay out of it
Professor
Professor
What did you say to Tai-chit this afternoon?
Why did he dig his kidney out?
It is not good to talk in here
I am leaving here soon.
I will tell you some other time
But you have to remember...
You and me are doing the same thing
Miss Choi. What is your relationship with
defendant Fok Tin-yam
Fok Tin-yam was my boyfriend and we lived together
Defendant Fok Tin-yam, on 16th May this year
You was accused drug keeping and
drug production crimes
You are the one who made him to the prison
in the court that day
How come you are here to
say something for him suddenly?
I should not hurt someone I love
Seeing him suffered...
made me realize that I am the one who suffer most
I was a chemistry professor
The Ketamine that the police had found
were made in the university laboratory by me
Fuk Tin-yam said he would like to break up with me
I didn't want to let him go
I said if he wants to leave me...
I will frame him on
drug producing and drug keeping
I'm wrong. I'm sorry
Please forgive me
You are the only one that I really like
According to the new statement from the deponent
My litigant is absolutely innocent
Therefore my honor,
please announce the verdict soon
Court!
The result of jury's vote is 5:2
It is declared that Fok Tin-yam's is not guilty
on drug producing and drug keeping
He could be released immediately
Court!
I've helped you with this
I've told you that it would be fine
I've told you that you could do it
Thank you
Come on
Tai-chit was disappeared from
the hospital last night
Officer Lai would like to know
what actually had happened to Da Chit
Someone don't want me to investigate further
Inform Officer Lai that I need to get out
as soon as possible
Tai-chit is in trouble. I heard something
I suspect that the head of triad police
is Cheuk King-chuen, Senior Assistant Commissioner
Ho Yiu-lung, Senior Superintendent
Telephone number, 28608861
Senior Assistant Commissioner of
Criminal Department, Cheuk King-chuen
Telephone number, 28602536
Cheuk King-chuen
Cheuk King-chuen will be promoted to
Commission next month
We've brought Tai-chit here
I will take care of the rest
The Commission successor has excellent ability
Thank you, Officer Cheuk
The hospital had already
re-connected Tai-chit's kidney
However the function of his kidney was damaged
Professor, you are going to adopt an ambivalence
for kidney transplantation
The duration of operation is 3 hours
If there is no question, we are going to
give you anesthesia now
No problem. Thank you, doctor
A pain of a criminal
could exchange several hundreds of life
This viewpoint has nothing wrong
However I would like to know the view of those
who have not raised their hands
Torture is intruding human's right
Moreover...
If the person is innocent
We are even doubly wrong
What you've said is comprehensive
However if we go back to
the point of utilitarianism
According to the years of experience on
anti-terrorism in the United States
The result they have achieved is...
the information they got from torturing
has very low dependability
As it's related to a lot of lives
Shall we try even
if we have 1% of chance only?
Maybe we should change to another question
In order to make the criminal
tell us where the bomb is
The only way is...
to torture his daughter who is only 5 years old
Will you do that?
Father
Chit
One month ago,
we had transplanted a kidney for Chit
He has recovered already
However I actually...
You have to thank professor
It was professor who donated his kidney to you
He had laid on the bed for one week for you
I don't deserve you doing this for me
You could abandon your life
because of our believe
It's nothing that we provide you with
a kidney in a safe and comfy place
Please get well soon.
We are waiting for you to come back
Laughing was right
Cheuk King-chuen's informer
is a doctor in black market
One month ago, he had bought a kidney
in the black market
and transplanted it for a kid
That kid is Tai-chit's son
We couldn't figure out before on
why Tai-chit was willing to do a scapegoat
We know that he wants to give his son
a kidney transplant
It's time for Laughing to come out
Bring all the information and wait for me
in the entrance of the car park
Yes, sir.
Go!
Go!
Stop the car!
Officer Lai
Officer Lai is dead
All the documents that
proved your identity are all gone
Officer Lai died in front of me.
He vomited a lot of blood
I am afraid
We were talking couple minutes ago
I'm only twenty something
I have never been to Japan nor Europe
I have a lot of things that haven't finished yet
I don't want to die like this
Why?
Why did Officer Lai choose me to
be your coordinator
Why is it me that discovered
Tai Chit's case is suspicious
I have to face all these all of sudden,
I don't know how to handle at all
I don't know how to handle
Carmen
You are doing very well already
Today, the topic I would like to discuss with you is
"Extort a Confession through Torture"
Suppose the police had arrested
a terrorist suspect
We also know that he had placed
a time bomb in a crowded place
You're back?
They said that you went for an operation
Yes. The doctor let me come back after a week
What's up?
Are you worrying about me?
You joined the triad society because of me
and that's why your leg became like this
If you didn't need to pay for my study,
you wouldn't be like this...
I am fine now
Don't worry. I have promised you...
But your leg... your leg
What happened to my leg
Look
It's fine. I can walk and run, right?
It's fine
Really?
It's fine
There is a psychologist
who is going to evaluate for you
Come with me
Last time, you mentioned that
you are doing the same thing as I am
What do you mean?
I was just guessing last time
Carmen confirmed it already
You met Carmen?
You are an undercover sent to the jail by
Security Bureau to investigate corrupted police
So am l
Officer Lai didn't tell me
he had sent someone else here
My purpose is same as yours
which is to investigate if Tai Chit
is really crazy or he is pretending
He hasn't told me about you
He hasn't ever told me about you
How do you explain that
after you've talked to Tai Chit
He dragged his kidney out
That day in the canteen
I decided to use my last chance to comfort him
and see if he has anything to say
But he was not very conscious
and was so crazy dragged his kidney out
and kept saying that he was to save his son
I am quite sure he has illusion at that time
I suspect that someone actually fed him
a huge amount of psychological medicine
That means someone doesn't want us
to investigate anything
Now Officer Lai had died.
No one knows I am an undercover
Have you thought of breaking out of prison?
You are a murderer for a life time in here
You only have chance to prove that
you are innocent after you escape
Is it possible?
Next week, there is
an annual fire evacuation exercise
Actually if I fail on my appeal,
I will leave that day
Trust me. That day is going to be a chaos
I will be locked together with Ye Po
Sir, I'm almost done. Thank you
Let's go
My name is Fok Tin-yam
It was the prison consultation team
who sent me here for you
You have applied protection and
being locked separately
ls there anyone bullies you in here?
Who will bully a crippled person like me
It was me who doesn't want to see people
Actually I am here to let you know one thing
Because I know...
that you have applied for Open University
but was rejected
I am the one who rejected you
Why didn't you allow me to study?
Why do you need to study the law?
To appeal for yourself?
What could you do if you could catch up?
What could you do if you could appeal
Even if you leave the jail with a diploma
do you think you will be
given one more chance by the world?
Don't be silly
There is one thing called labeling
Once you are a prisoner,
you are a prisoner for a lifetime
Yes. I am the worst
What else can I do except killing myself?
How could you be fooled by the world?
If the world is unfair to you,
you have to fight back
If you are not happy with the system.
You have to join the system as to break it
Study law? What is law?
Most of the law...
were created by the beneficiary
so as to protect themselves
The world shouldn't be like what it is now
and could be different from what it is now
Black, doesn't have to be black
White, doesn't have to be white
All the revolution in the history...
started from breaking the law
I want you to join us and
change the world together
Sir, everything is ready
Let's start when it's ready
The fire evacuation exercise is commencing.
Fire in area A
Area A copy
All areas on fire
Yes, all areas on fire
Hurry up
Evacuate all the prisoners
in area A and area B now
OK, hurry up
One by one
Move faster
The firemen are standing by in area b
Good. Hurry up
Main gate of area A is closed.
Ready to open all the auxiliary gate
Be quick
Firemen standby
Firemen start to move into fire area of area A
Prisoners of area B
are leaving auxiliary gate of area B
Prisoners of area A is passing through
the pathways of area C and D
According to the Financial Report 2010
Correctional Services Department
had used the prisoner to work
and had earned more than 300 million dollars
for the whole year
However after implying the minimum wage ordinance
those prisoners who have been working for 6 days
remain 500 a month
which is one tenth of the minimum wage
What is happening?
Shut the broadcasting system now
I am going to take care of it
Do you think it is fair?
A pack of cigarette had increased to
But the prisoner's wage has never been adjusted
We are being exploited, bullied and
pressed by the people who have power
We have to fight back
Let's fight back together! Release the prison
Unfair... Unfair...
Shut up! Shut up!
Let's fight back together! Release the prison
Shut up! Shut your mouth!
Go! Go!
Go to hell
Go...
I'm not going
Go!
Go, Officer Laughing
What are you doing? Stop it!
Put down the hose
Prisoners escape! Prisoners escape!
Prisoners escape!
Go! Go!
- I am not going...
- Let's go
Go
I am not going! I am not going...
I won't go away if you don't leave here
Be quick! We are leaving! (Burmese)
As a member of Correctional Services Department,
why did you assist the prisoner to escape?
I did not assist the prisoner to escape
I was to stop them from escaping, Sir!
Many people witnessed...
that you used the fire host to shoot
the member of Correctional Services Department
I did shoot. But I was shooting the prisoners
and stop them from escaping
If it wasn't me, there won't be
only 2 prisoners that had escaped
But you were shooting your peers
It was them who rushed here and
being shot by themselves
I can't stop them, Sir!
Come
Professor!
Seeing you is knowing you. Hello
I've brought someone you want to see
Thank you
Let me introduce to you. Miss Sa Po Yau
Do you know her?
She is in charge of the Golden Triangle
So what? Just a drug trafficker
The poppy you planted is harming the whole world
I think you are not very familiar with them
as well as the Golden Triangle
Do you know that Golden Triangle
was a place where no plants grown
There is only one plant can be planted,
which is poppy
I don't know how you see poppy
But I think it is the most
beautiful flower in the world
Because it represents my living
It allows me to live
Only if I can continue to live,
I will continue to plant poppy
I don't mind whatever you call me at all
Do you know how many people you had harmed?
But do you know that they were being harmed, too
In those years, European needed to
spread their colonialism
The Eastern Indian company of Britain
had made the opium trade
They brought the poppy seed to the Golden Triangle
and taught them how to plant poppy
The local people had tried very hard to
work and earn their living
Compare to a lot of people
who live in the society of capitalism
who could only think of
stock market and real estate...
as well as investments
who keeps eating each other up...
They should receive more respect
This is the second time that
I come to Hong Kong for a trade
We had some incident last time
which made me lost a fortune
My people had starved for 3 months
Tomorrow, I will trade with a group of cops
who you think are illegal
By then, you will see
who are the ones that really harming the society
Come
Cheuk King-chuen
Don't be nervous. Let's see what's next
I want you to know what we are doing
Mr. Cheuk
Please check
Ok
Don't take this dirty money!
Papa (Burmese)
Sa Po Yau, don't repeat the mistakes again
Give me the gun
What does he wanna do?
How many times I've been telling you not to
do the drug trafficking
Have you listened to me?
build an empire and need a lot of money
I was ready to fight hard
Finally, I was sentenced to
thirty years imprisonment
This is the result of drug trafficking
In these 15 years
I've been thinking on how to rescue you
I don't want you to rescue me!
I should pay for my guilt
You are not helping me if you help me to escape
but you are helping Ye Po
You personally said that
there would be our own national flag
We have our dignity, are we?
I have never forgotten
So why you keep on planting the poppy?
Can I not to plant the poppy?
If I don't plant it,
many people will lose their lives
So you tell me, in order to plant the poppy
How many times we fight hard with
the government force and other drug traffickers?
How many people had died?
So do you know when you are in the prison
how many people from our end
were died from starving
Don't come over!
Papa... (Burmese)
Papa... (Burmese)
Papa... Papa... (Burmese)
Remember... (Burmese)
Papa... (Burmese)
your ideal... (Burmese)
your ideal... (Burmese)
Go!
Don't kill him!
Give him to me. I will persuade him
Is it necessary?
I really... want you to know what we are doing
and what our believe is
What is so great about your believe?
It was police colludes with drug trafficker
Laughing
I didn't bring the drug out
All those drugs were brought by
Cheuk King-chuen instead
Professor has his own way of thinking
Cheuk King-chuen had given us the confiscated drug
and left it for us to look for a buyer
We found a buyer when we closed the deal
He came to arrest us and confiscated the drug
in his police identity
He had arrested the buyer who harm the people most
Those drug could be retrieved and being sold again
If we keep doing in this way
We don't need any drug in future
But my father doesn't know this
Ye Po has done nothing wrong
neither do I
You are breaking the law
No one wants Ye Po to die, it was an accident
What do you mean by breaking the law?
Do you know why people break the law?
It was because they could not...
have a fair treat in a legal way in this world
He can only get his things back in an illegal way
Tell me why homosexual is illegal?
Why mercy killing is also illegal
Because law is legislated by human
But why do we need to follow...
the law which is legislated by
other people and is unfair?
I think it is fine if the aim is correct, right?
Join us
Excuse me, I understand every single word
that you had said
But I don't understand when they mean
I only know that I will stop you guys
How do you stop us?
What identity you use to stop us?
You are an escaped prisoner now
You cannot threat us at all
Mister. I would like to...
give him some time to think it thoroughly
Can we just let him go and think for a while?
Let him go
Keep your stuff safely
It can help you to retrieve your identity
It's me
Carmen! Carmen...
Please check the relationship
of Fok Tin-yam with the police for me
Why do you want to see me?
I am just an ordinary people
I applied Executive Officer, not a police
I don't know how to handle an escaped convict
I am not an escaped convict.
You know I am innocent
Don't force me!
I said I am an ordinary clerk
What do you mean by ordinary?
Does ordinary means care of nothing?
Does it mean you can keep your hands off
even if you see people committing crime?
I am an ordinary police, too
But no matter how ordinary I am...
there is something in the world that we have to do
Papa! Rest in peace! (Burmese)
I'm sorry. I didn't expect things
would go like this
There would be sacrifices when we have big goals
I'll go to Golden Triangle and visit you later
Bring your girlfriend with you
I want to let you see...
the most evil and beautiful flower, poppy
Does it looks like...
the yellow reed field that we've been to?
She is my patient
But she treats me as her husband
Does she have mental problems?
It depends on your point of view
It is normal to obey the powerful in this world
Those who doesn't go with
the main stream of the society are crazy
Her current situation is the most
comfortable situation in her subconscious mind
It is the happiest living status
I don't think there is any problem
Actually you know her husband, too
I know Sa Po Yau is a woman long time ago
But I didn't know she is a beautiful woman
So you better grab the chance to look
Ether Club owes you more than
a hundred million dollars on the drug
Do you really want to kill me?
Do you think I don't have the guts to kill you?
If everyone refuses to pay like you...
How could the people from my end survive?
Do you know that they've been working very hard
for what?
For the blames from all over the world
and 50 US dollars a month
It's only enough for one person's living
What do you Ether Club had done?
You don't need to do anything
You just need to be an agent
who earns the most money out of it
What kind of world it is?
This world only helps those capitalist...
who eats the flash and blood from us, the labor
I can stand that you take 99 dollars out of 100
Why can't you give us the remaining dollar?
If I don't bring back the money,
my people will starve to death
A day's lateness would cost a life of
our children that die from starving
I cannot die, too
I've promised my wife that
I will go back to pick her up
I know Ether Club has money in Swiss Bank
I am trying to withdraw the money
I will return the money to you very soon
Ok
I'll give you 5 children's lives
Let him go
I will return the money to you after 5 days!
The information you want
The list of police
who attended the professor's course
Cheuk King-chuen and Tai Chit.
They've already started...
to participate in the course organized
between professor ad police five years ago
Their attendance had exceeded
Moreover, look at this
After calculation, they've seized
from the drug trafficking case that
the police cleared in Tuen Mun
It worth 600 million dollars in the market
It is the biggest cocaine case
in Hong Kong history
including one Hong Kong people
and his Colombian wife
The 6 western people arrested earlier
were already prosecuted for drug trafficking
It will be mentioned in
the Tuen Mun Magistracy tomorrow
Office Lai had brought me to
Director of Public Prosecutions
They should be willing to see me
Please hand these two things over to him for me
If he wants to see me after
seeing these two things, please arrange
OK.
I've already given the video and
document to the professor
What did you say?
I'm sorry
After Office Lai died, professor came to me
I agree with his believe
But I really couldn't get over myself
I've betrayed you
"Don't worry, I will help you Fok Tin-yam"
I was guessing last time
Carmen had confirmed it
You met Carmen?
Please give these two things to him for me
If he wants to see me after
seeing these two things, please arrange
The only way to make the suspect
to tell where the bomb is
is to torture him until he tells
So you are actually on professor's side
Professor has been hoping that you are on his side
Impossible!
He gives you a way out.
You don't have to against him
I am a police!
I will never befriend with a criminal!
He is violating the law, not committing a crime
He is a revolutionist
Revolution needs people's blood, Laughing
You must trust professor, right?
He really wants to change this world
as it has no justice
This world needs to be changed
But not by his way
Between bastion of iron and an egg
I will always stay by egg's side
It's obvious that your professor
is not going to give me a way out
Help!
Go!
I'm only twenty something
I have a lot of things that haven't done yet
I don't want to die like this
Professor. How is it
My kidney is in Tai Chit's body
After he died, I feel like a part of me had died
The feeling is strange
Who are you?
I'm asking who you are
What is your relationship with
the person with you just now?
I am asking you. What is your relationship with
the person with you just now?
The informer and the police.
Person in charge and undercover
One kills, one revenges
I killed his woman. So what?
You are very cruel
If I am not cruel to people
I am cruel to those who care about me
I will shoot anyone if necessary
But he let you go in this situation...
means he treats you like a buddy
He let me go because he is a cop
Besides being a cop...
he is also the deceased's husband
I think your stakes are too high this time
Or maybe... for the code inside the rings?
For the six hundred million US dollar that
Ether Club has in the Swiss Bank?
However what a pity, the rings were broken
Did Sa Po Yau send you?
I don't know any Sa Po Yau
I think you've got it wrong
But I also think you know too much
You just said he let you go because he is a cop
This is the most incorrect thing
that you have said
Because I am a cop, too!
His sacrifice is worth something
Nothing would be wasted
Do you think Tai Chit should die?
How about Carmen?
It's you who sent Tai Chit to kill Laughing
I admire the professor very much
He could hurt his body like that
in order to save you
Chit Junior and I are very grateful to him
If you are really grateful to the professor,
words are not enough
There are two people who will harm the professor
One is Laughing
I know what I should do
The other is you
I promise you that
I will take good care of your son
Tai Chit should have died in the prison
As he life is saved, I don't want him to die again
To be honest, you, myself and Tai Chit
are walking the same path
Although we are of different ranks, however
we are on the same boat after all.
You treated him like that...
which violated our principle
and sacrificed Carmen
I will be the Chief of Police next week
All Hong Kong police are under my command
If there is any mistake at this point
we would have wasted all our effort
Before Carmen died...
I have been spying on the conversations
between her and Laughing
I admit that I am unhappy.
But I have never blamed it on her
and I had never thought of killing Carmen
If nothing else happened
and you are not making the same mistake
I will keep this video only to myself
as a private collection
I wholeheartedly hope that
you could be your Chief of
Police dutifully next week
Move to the right in threes, right turn
One Squad, by the left, quick march
Left, right, left, right
Two Squad, by the left, quick march
By the right, eyes right
Check up
Eyes right
Check up
I want to go to the washroom
Congratulations!
What are you doing?
Go away!
Go away! All of you!
Go away! Go away!
Put down the gun!
Don't follow me or I will shoot him dead
Put down the gun!
- Put down the gun!
- Put down the gun!
Step back 50 meters, all of you
Or I will shoot him right the way!
Step back!
And I want to see Fok Tin-yam
I want him to stand right
in front of me within 3 minutes
Close the curtains
Laughing, you are dead
I've prepared for it
However before I die...
I will not let you control 30 thousands policemen
Laughing
I am Fok Tin-yam
I am coming in now. Do you want to see me?
Then open the door
Laughing, don't do anything silly
Let us work together
I promise that you will be fine
An escaped murderer
who abducts the Chief of Police
Can I be fine?
Do you think you are God?
When you say I am fine I will be fine
I can help you get your identity back
Can you?
What if I do it?
If you would only work with me
after shooting him dead
I don't mind at all
Cheuk King-cheun, you hear that
You are no different from an ant
He doesn't care if you live or die
Tai Chit can sacrifice himself
for a word from Officer Cheuk
I think Officer Cheuk would
sacrifice himself for my belief
Are you Officer Cheuk?
Shoot, then
Why don't you shoot?
Bang!
After that sound,
you will feel content and not hateful
This is the feeling you want, right?
Why don't you shoot?
Ah yes. You haven't flipped the coin
so it's hard for you to decide
I had listened to your self-defend in the court
You said you had been an undercover 4 times
and you are the one who performs
most undercover tasks among all current police
Maybe you have been doing too much undercover work
Therefore you find it hard to
differentiate black and white in this world
There is no borderline between right and wrong
Therefore you need a coin to
make decisions every time
Because no matter what happens,
it is the coin's fault
Laughing, do you know?
This world shouldn't be like that
and cannot to be like that
Join us. Let's change the world together
You should know better about
Black and White heroes
Professor, you are good at talking
I feel touched every time I hear your saying
But I don't understand any of it
and I don't want to!
However there is one thing
you said that I do agree a lot
Laughing! Laughing...
I am violating the law, not committing a crime
That's what you have taught me, right?
I know you from head to toe already
When you studied in the United States.
In order to publicize your belief
you brought a gang of people to
wrack a fast food chain store
You grew in a single parent family
You had serious depression when you were young
You had tried to commit suicide
Do you still think of committing suicide now?
But I wouldn't let you die easily
If I shoot you dead
no one would know what crime you had committed
Do you need to flip a coin?
I can lend it to you
A 5 dollar coin minted in 1997
Someone from the sawmill picked it up for me
Because I am also a cop!
Can you recognize me?
It was you who taught me
If the world plays you, you cannot let it
If the world is unfair to you,
you have to fight back
I am listening. Why do you want to kill me?
Do you know...
Between bastion of iron and an egg
I will always take the egg's side
If you don't like people exploiting you,
don't exploit others
Let alone relying on Ether Club
You shouldn't help those
wealthy and powerful people
You have violated my belief
You had done wrong
Professor. Promise me. Take care of Paris!
It was you who sent someone to kill Michael
It was him who violated my belief
Therefore I don't want you to go on the same path
Step back! Step back...
Moreover, I want to see Fok Tin-yam
I want him to stand right
in front of me within 3 minutes
If I shoot you to die
no one would know what crime you had committed
Do you need to flip a coin?
I can lend it to you
Someone from the sawmill picked it up for me
It was you who sent someone to kill Michael
It was him who violated my belief
Get up...
We need to get married...
Michael!
You've killed Michael!
- Go! Go...
- Go! Go...
Put down your gun!
Actually violating the law and
committing a crime are two different things
Two different concepts
Why someone would violate the law
It is because they cannot
receive fair treatment...
from the world in a legal way
Therefore they resort to illegal ways
to get back what they should have
Therefore fairness and justice
is very important in this world
Father, see what I've caught
I have actually never seen this bug before
But how come it looks familiar
It's not strange
Your eyes did see it before
We had found the organ donation card
from the body of Jodie
Will you follow her wish to donate her organs?
What other bugs did you see?
A few more...
You don't have to bleed to have an ideal world
When there are people like Jodie
we are already living in an ideal world
This world shouldn't be like this
And cannot to be like this